“Doctor Mary, I* did something stupid and I can’t get my back to stop hurting. So John said I had to come see you.” We both laughed
“It must be something bad because you never come to see me if you don’t absolutely have to!”
“True. My brother’s girlfriend (who I really liked before this) broke up with him and gave him one week to move out. I was helping him and lifted a box that was kind of heavy, it didn’t seem that heavy at the time, but I heaved and it didn’t budge. So I had to heave harder and I think I tweaked something then and my back has not been the same since. I had to keep carrying boxes, of course, but that night when I went home, it was sore and I put ice and heat on it and took some Tylenol and it felt pretty good by bed time. But then I woke up and it was worse. I did heat and ice and tylenol and it got better. But the next day it was worse again and then it stopped getting better when I did the ice and heat. I’m thirty five and I sound like my grandmother!
“I tried adding ibuprofen and naprosyn, and that didn’t help. I did a bunch of yoga classes, and some helped when I was doing them, but not afterwards, and some didn’t help at all. I even tried massage - which is so expensive! - and that helped the most, but I can’t do that all the time, and it only lasted a while. She said maybe my health insurance will pay for it if you write me a prescription. I don’t know what you can do for me, Doctor Mary, but I hate this! I can’t do my life. I have to take the kids everywhere after school, and do everything to keep the house running, and try to feed us halfway nutritious meals, and squeeze my job in at the corners because the extra money sure is nice. I’ve done this job for so long and they know me and know I’ll get everything done even if I’m having a bad week, but I can’t keep doing this with this back pain and I have to!”
“That sounds awful, Jane! But, I think I can help you. We have talked before about about how you’re doing a lot and maybe you want to ask the kids or John to do some stuff around the house, and you have your reasons why you don’t want to do that and I understand, but I would like to gently point out that maybe there is something you could have someone else do. You take better care of the dog than you do of yourself, and if something happens to you, who will take care of the dog?”
“I know. I know. You’re right. This has really made me slow down and let some stuff go, especially the housework. It hurts so much to run the vacuum that I don’t do it much, and I guess you’re right that nothing terrible has happened with more dust on our floor, but it’s not as nice.”
“It’s food for thought, Jane. I know you’ll think about it. But you came here for your back.” I ask her the usual questions about her back pain. None elicits a worrisome answer.
“Let’s take a look. Come stand here in front of me, turn around and show me where it hurts.”
Most people with difficult-to-diagnose back pain do exactly the same motion at this point. They rub the back of their hand along their back right at the transition between the lower back and the hips. Then they usually flip their hand over and poke at their back a few times with their fingers. “Sometimes it hurts here or here,” they’ll say. They’ll tell me which side hurts more or hurt first, but usually it’s both sides.
I observe their posture and tell them to put their weight evenly on both feet with their arms at their sides. I check to see if they are level or if one leg gives the impression of being longer than the other. I’ll mention this if I see it.
Sometimes I see mild scoliosis - that’s a sideways curvature in the spine that’s not supposed to be there. When I mention it, some people will say they’ve had it for years, and some will be surprised to learn they have it.
I poke their sacroiliac joints, which I often find to be tender. I palpate the top of their iliac crest, which I rarely find to be tender. I run my finger down the bones in the middle of the back. Those are rarely tender, but if they are, we’re likely headed to a firm diagnosis about what’s wrong. Usually, as I do this, the patient will say as I do these probes going down their back that the probing doesn’t hurt, but the pain is near some of it. And the most likely place for that pain is usually around the third lumbar vertebra to the top of the sacrum.
<I like how there is a firm diagnosis here. Are there other points in this process where there’s a firm diagnosis?>
I palpate the muscles to the sides of the vertebra. When the person is standing, the muscles are engaged, and should be firm and nontender. I should feel them as discrete entities, but not hard ones. If I find a tight muscle, especially one that’s tender, I point it out.
Next, I have them lie down face up on the exam table. There, I maneuver the patient to assess for disk problems and hip problems. I’ve watched as they walked and climbed up on the table and got out of the chair. That’s part of the exam, too.
I then have the patient sit back down in the chair. That completes my exam.
In Jane’s case, I found some muscle spasms. Her posture was not perfect, but everything else looked pretty normal. I shared these findings with her, then launched into my Human Backs 101 lecture.
“Our backs are an absolute marvel of engineering if you think about it. They are amazingly flexible, moving in all directions and twisting, yet able to withstand the impact of falling down the stairs or being attacked by a lion, all while keeping a soft, fibrous core safe in the middle. You know, of course, that an injury to the spinal cord is very serious, and the bones are set up to articulate and move against each other so that we can do our incredible feats of flexibility, all the while keeping the spinal cord free from harm.
“As you would expect, the vertebrae have multiple joints against each other so that we can do all the crazy movements we do, but also to stop us from stretching too far. There are muscles for each of these motions: side to side, front to back, twisting clockwise and counterclockwise. If something changes suddenly in how hard these muscles are pulling, like if you pull against something that is too heavy for you to lift, the muscle assumes that part of your spine has broken and it needs to do everything it can to stabilize your spine. The muscle becomes rocklike and will not allow that part of your spine to move. It thinks it’s protecting your spinal cord.
“Then once it gets used to being contracted, even if you get it to relax and everything else goes back to its usual state, the muscle has a hard time staying relaxed. If anything goes even slightly wrong to remind it of what had happened, it goes right back into spasm. ‘Oh! I relaxed too soon!’
“So, you have to get it to relax and stay relaxed for many days. Then it will go back to its baseline state. But I’ve noticed that once an area is tweaked, it usually becomes ready to be tweaked even years later. It’s like it never really forgets.
“Some of the muscles are tiny. None of them communicates with the others. So sometimes, you might have a tiny muscle convinced it’s saving the spinal cord from destruction. Meanwhile, the tiny muscle is pulling against a big muscle. This is something you notice. You can make the tiny muscle hurt less by consciously relaxing the big muscle. However, this puts your posture out of alignment. The other muscles start noticing you’re out of alignment. They assume something is wrong, and they get involved in trying to correct it. Now you have muscles that should be pulling that are instead relaxing, and muscles that should be relaxing are pulling. Despite this, your spine doesn’t return to the correct position. Meanwhile, there’s a cascade of effects with your back muscles.
“I can give you a muscle relaxant that will help with that.
“Yoga is good, but doing yoga won’t solve your problem. What yoga is good for is preventing back problems.
“Massage is more likely to be helpful, as is physical therapy. You need something to get those back muscles relaxed. I can do prescriptions for both.
“What questions do you have?”
“I don’t really have any. It all makes sense. I’m thinking about my uncle and his sticking vertebra from arthritis. It’s the same thing, isn’t it? His muscles pull against the stuck vertebra and then it lets go suddenly and they go into spasm.”
“Exactly. The mechanism of injury can be picking up something too heavy, a sudden change in momentum like a car accident, a stuck vertebra, or even putting your back in a relatively unstable position and then lifting something heavy. Our backs are really marvels, but they are also kind of fragile.
”Let me give you an exercise to do to think about your back. When you’re lying in bed all relaxed, feel your back muscles. They should be soft and relaxed. Then, later in the day, sit up straight on a hard chair. You can feel some of your back muscles are soft and relaxed, while others are engaged, but not rock hard. Move around slightly, forward and back, and side to side. Notice the changes in which muscles are engaged. Then move your hand slightly up, down, and to the side, and do it again. Different muscles will engage at different times. You will have a new appreciation for why it takes babies until they’re six months or older to sit up!”
I give Jane a prescription for a muscle relaxant along with the usual warnings about side effects: sleepiness and mental fogginess. So, she should start with a small dose. I also give her a prescription for physical therapy and one for massage.
“Your back has been spasming for two weeks. It’s going to take at least twice as long for it to recover, but you should see some improvement by two weeks. If you don’t seem to be following that trajectory, give me a call. I feel confident that this will work.”
“Oh, me, too! Thanks, Doctor Mary! You were running on time today. I can get a coffee before I pick the kids up from school!”
“Oh, good! No need to stop at the desk today. Let’s get you on with your day.”
I did not expect to see Jane again until her annual physical, but in a month, she called and told the nurse that she was not getting better. She thought maybe a referral to a pain clinic would help. Her uncle had gone to one that really helped him with dry needling. She wanted to try it.
I considered having Jane come in for another visit. Could I have missed anything? It had seemed so simple and straightforward. She was busy and didn’t have time for a doctor’s visit that would most likely to yield no new information. I had the nurse call her back. I suggested we do an X-ray, which Jane agreed to. I gave her a referral to the pain clinic.
At any given moment, most of my patients are in their usual state, doing their lives, not thinking about their bodies. I don’t worry about them. Many others are engaged in therapy or medical care and are on a path that clearly is getting them better. I worry a little bit about them. A few are on diagnostic journies to We Know Not Where. These are the ones who keep me up at night. Jane’s story was so typical for muscle spasm. All that is atypical is how long she’s taking to get better, especially for someone so young and healthy.
She’s busy. She’s probably not doing her exercises that faithfully. I decide I do not need to lose sleep over not bringing her in for another visit. I move on to my next task.
*All patients discussed here are amalgams of patients with garden variety pain and any resemblance to one of the approximately 10% of humanity that have this issue is accidental.
**Nothing here is meant to be or should be taken as personal medical advice. If you want personal medical advice, see your personal medical doctor.



I, too, am a primary care physician and I really enjoy your essays. I love our profession and you narrate it really well. Thank you.
I wish all I had was mild scoliosis. Mine is severe enough that when I stand, my legs splay outwards, which puts horrendous pressure around my knees. That is coupled with the neck pain, etc., even with all the surgeries, casts, and braces that I had to endure as a child. At that time, the doctors did the best they knew how about this troublesome condition.
I loved this article. Please don't ever stop. You do a remarkable job of bringing our aches and pains to light.